Skip to main content

Review: Coralline by Neil Gaiman – In which I get far too much into the idea of scaring children

Novel: Children's story, supernatural, horror, fantasy. Contains disturbing themes. 

This review contains minor spoilers.

I read this book quite a while ago so do forgive me if I am unable to give you a perfectly clear vision of the book and my feeling on it. But to get straight down to the point, it’s good.
Basically, a girl named Coraline is being ignored by her parents and doesn't enjoy living in the new house they have moved to. When she finds a door in the wall, that leads to the bricked-up segment of the building, being extremely bored and curious she goes inside and after traveling through a tunnel she finds herself in an exact replica of her house.

Except her parents are different, they seek her attention instead of the other way around, and this Otherworld, as it is referred to is full of amazing and wonderful gifts, just for her. And the grounds surrounding the house are is just as amazing. The only problem is that if Coraline wants to stay here, then she is going to have to let the Other Mother remove her eyes and replace them with buttons.

I really enjoyed it, it was imaginative, dark, interesting, and had a good lesson. I hope that, when and if I have children, they too will enjoy the book. It’s not just a “kid’s book” though, Gaiman knows how to make the story interesting enough and the character unique enough that it doesn't really matter what age you are, the story will still intrigue you, and you will still end up rooting for Coraline as well as her friend, dubbed only “the cat”.

Personally, I never bought into the age grouping of books; I don’t think that stories should be made for a certain age group. Which is not to say that there shouldn't be limits on what our children can read, but I have a passionate hatred for the censorship of books and I think we should be less ready to steer our children away from dark subjects.

Which brings us to the question, "Is Coraline scary?" 

 To me, no it wasn't. I read it many years ago when I was younger and I did not find it scary. I felt for the character, and I may have been creeped out at one point or another, but I don’t think I was scared. It certainly has a creepy atmosphere and I think that if you are looking for a dark book to give a child that still won’t be too chilling, then Coraline is your book. Neil Gaiman explained that adults are smart enough to know how creepy a concept is, but to children, it just seems exciting. 

I don’t understand why so many critics compare this book to Alice and Wonderland, as the tone is completely different. The concept is vaguely similar, I suppose? Girl, portal, insane world. But Coraline is a well-defined story, with a lot of well-defined characters, while Alice is an experiment in absurdism. It's imaginative, but there's never a sense of danger or tension because the whole thing is supposed to amuse children, not excite them.

 Coraline also stands out from Peter Pan ,or The Wizard of Oz in tone and sense of humor. Its villain is much more threatening than any of those in the aftermentioned stories, and the message is on par with them all, if not surpassing in how it demonstrates the truth that no one truly wants everything (although stories about children wandering to better worlds, usually have a core theme of reality being always better than fantasy). 

I’d say it is a Great, with a wonderful ending, a great beginning, and many interesting little bits all the way in between. If you're looking for a good book to get for a child then I suggest this one and if you are looking for some dark, eerie concepts then you can do worse than to pick up this book yourself and give it a go.

Thank you for reading & have a nice day! 
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Review: Freakonomics by Stephen J. Dubner and Steven Levitt – In which Economics prove to be cooler than Algebra

Novel: Nonfiction THE CHARACTERIZATION. WAS. INCREDIBLE. I jest of course, as this book contains no characters and really isn’t like any books I have previously reviewed. This will make it difficult to review it, as in the end, the purchase really just depends on whether you would buy and read a book SIMPLY to know some interesting facts and get a slightly skewed perspective. Levitt says at the end, that he knows the book won’t make a big difference. It might make you treat a few people in certain jobs differently, it might make you distrust common knowledge more often. But other than that, I can scarcely say that the book will leave an emotional impact on you. It’s not necessarily boring so much as…not engaging. Let me start from the beginning. The book was written by Steven Levitt, an economist, and Stephen Dubner, a writer. Levitt is apparently something of a wild card in the economist biz, as he comes to conclusions which disturb many, and enjoys looking in...
2 comments
Read more

Review: Zen in the art of writing by Ray Bradbury – The literary equivalent of getting high

Ray Bradbury is my favorite writer. I love his short stories, his novels, his poems, and Fahrenheit 451 is my favorite book of all time. I wanted a book that would make me a better writer but would not be boring and tedious. So when I found out that there was a book by him, about writing, I decided that I had to have it. I had looked up some good books about writing and the moment I saw the name Bradbury I clicked on it. I scrolled through a list of quotes from the book and was fascinated, there are many great quotes from the book, and each one seemed to have life energy and being to them. So after reading only several quotes from the list I became very hyped for the book. And I was not disappointed because Bradbury writes with enthusiasm and honesty. While starting the first two chapters I became so enwrapped with the book that I went outside and began yelling the words out like a preacher quoting the bible (I was not drunk at the time, I was just very happy and really I’m j...
2 comments
Read more

Short story: The Long Trail

When I was younger, I was walking on a trail. My family would often visit trails on vacation, we were not the hotel, lounge about kind of vacation family. My mother and father both loved the wilderness, as did I and the majority of my four siblings. But this particular trail was longer and more tedious than any other trail in memory. It seemed to stretch on forever, and the gravel it was made from certainly didn’t improve the condition of our feet. I can’t recall how many times I had to stop because my legs or the legs of one of my siblings hurt. But we trudged on nonetheless, our stomachs growling all the way. Our whole family wasn’t together, my father was up ahead of all of us, my mother was behind me, Jacob (my second younger brother) and Noah (my brother) with our little sister Lilly. My older brother, Gabriel, was bringing up the rear. I remember Lilly catching up, and us stopping to stare at some deathly white worms, which lay on the surface of a stream, spotted a...
2 comments
Read more