Skip to main content

Review: Mrs. Frisbee and the Rats of NIMH by Robert C. O'Brien – Rats! Mice! Other...expletives...

Novel: Children's book, adventure. 


I loved the "The Secret of NIMH" animated film as a child; it was dark and thought-provoking, and still “Kid friendly”. It was like a less brutal version of Watership down. So I decided I should read the book.


I was not disappointed, mostly. But the disappointment only stemmed from the book being considerably tamer than the Don Bluth movie (A thing indeed!), the book was still quite the experience, had some very interesting ideas, and made me think while still being targeted at children. This I have to applaud, as I can not stand the dumbing down of media for the "benefit" of children. I believe it to be detrimental, to say the least.

The plot is this, Mrs. Frisby, a mouse, has to visit the dangerous and mysterious rats that live under the thorn bush after her son gets caught with the fever and she has to move her entire house (A brick) with him in it, before the farmer uses his tractor to plow the field. It has its fair share of tension, and it has a likable protagonist and some fairly interesting side characters. And the story resolves in a neat, well done, and semi-symbolic way.

I fear, however, that I was too old when I read it. It just...somewhat bored me. But that doesn't mean that the book is bad, I just picked it up a few years too late. I read it when I was thirteen or fourteen and I am sure that I would have loved it if I had been just a year or two younger. So if you are thinking about picking it up for someone ages 6-12 then I suggest you do so. Then again, not everyone is the same, and I like to think were all a bit different.

So this book might bore a six-year-old, or it could fascinate a twenty-year-old, it depends on your personality. But if you were expecting it to be as dark as the movie, then you will probably be a bit disappointed. Which again is not a bad thing necessarily; the book has its own legs to stand on and is a fine experience.

I rate it mostly Good with a few parts bordering on Great (If you haven’t read any of my other reviews then this will show you how I rate books = Awful - Bad - Good - Great – Brilliant

Ultimately, the book is a classic for a reason and I think it deserves the awards which it received. If you are looking for a good book to give to a child to pre-teen relative, then this book is a pretty good option.

Thank  you for reading and have a nice day!
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Review: Borrasca by C. K. Walker (Bourasca? Borraskwa?! ¿¿Boruscka??)

Novel: Thriller, horror. Contains violence and disturbing imagery.  Warning: This review contains minor spoilers.             Do you like tragic thrillers, bordering on horror? Stories which seem like they originate from the pits of humanity which we do not understand and do not wish to? Small towns with big secrets? Twists that you know are coming from a mile away, but find yourself too surrounded by fog to know the nature of this twist until it is footsteps are right upon you and your heart is tearing to get out of your rib cage???             If any of these apply to you (or god forbid, them all), then Borrasca may just be the book for you.             The book starts out with the old “I’m moving to a small town because of my dad/mom’s new job. Of course, in this book, the change of job is a lot more...
Post a Comment
Read more

“Leap days” by Ian Bennett and “Anya’s Ghost” by Vera Brosgol - In which I get an invisible friend to help me cheat on the review

“Leap days” by Ian Bennett and “Anya’s Ghost” by Vera Brosgol Since these two graphic novels are somewhat similar and neither is particularly long, I figured reviewing them together would make sense. Both take place in high school and they are both coming of age stories. They also both involve a high schooler befriending a supernatural force who allows them to cheat in school. LEAP DAYS We’ll start with Leap Days since it’s the relatively less emotionally charged of the two.             I was surprised by this book. When it opens, it’s pretty grim. Being more realistic, it depicts the crushing boredom of school and the frustration of a sense that you are wasting your time and not really learning anything. The protagonist’s name is Jake and he drifts through the day, unknown by everyone and uninterested in everything. The only thing that snaps him out of the malaise aside from eventually getting to go home and go to sl...
Post a Comment
Read more

“Who Could That Be At This Hour?” By Lemony Snicket, in which Lemony sneaks around at too late of an hour

BE ADVISED! Along with containing minor spoilers, this review will be less about the book itself and more about the series of All The Wrong Questions and what it accomplishes and what it fails.  When I was around twelve or thirteen I first picked up “Who could that be at this hour?” It instantly captured my imagination with its air of intrigue and fascinating, semi-surreal setting. I grew up with the previous serious in the Lemony Snicketverse, “A Series of Unfortunate Events” and I hadn’t yet discovered my love of noir films so many of the tropes at play were initially lost on me. Looking back, older and more mature, I can see the seams. Already in the first book of a series of four, I can see the moments where the story lags. Having read all four books, I can see that while Handler is a master of delivering a powerful and clever satire, he doesn’t know how to break his own routines. It’s less noticeable in the first book than it is in later entries, but we are alrea...
Post a Comment
Read more